patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Local Little League Rejects Maplewood Firearms Dealer

An application by Matthew Carmel, owner of the gun dealership Constitution Arms, to sponsor a team for the South Orange-Maplewood Baseball League was rejected.

 

Why did the chicken cross the road? To avoid a law-abiding gun dealer who wanted to support his local baseball team.

In October of last year, I, Matthew Carmel, an NRA Certified Pistol Instructor,  licensed firearm dealer and gun designer, contacted the taxpayer-supported South  Orange Department of Recreational & Cultural Affairs seeking to sponsor a Little League baseball team. After months of correspondence, delays and bureaucratic avoidance, I finally received his  answer: "The Executive Committee of the league voted not to accept Constitution Arms as a sponsor." 
 
Although the committee refused to provide a reason for the denial, it is fairly clear  that someone has a problem with firearms and the shooting sports. But more galling is the kinds of sponsors the committee does accept. For example, one South Orange company is a chicken fast food chain called "Cluck-U Chicken," whose very name is a play on profanity.

A recent visit to their store revealed a tasteless (no pun  intended) T-shirt  prominently displayed at  the cash register. It showed a scantily clad woman suggestively posing in a small  bikini  captioned with the words  "Large Breasts, Juicy Thighs, Luscious Legs." They also had bumper stickers with the text "Hey!  Cluck-U" and a hand drawn cartoon with the words "Bite Me" next to their company name.

This kind of projected corporate image is somehow deemed more appropriate for children than a legitimate firearms dealer whose business is long-rooted in our American culture and traditions. Additional sponsors deemed appropriate  by the committee include businesses that promote the sale and use of  alcohol and/or  tobacco such as Bunny's, Libretti's, Park Wood Diner, QuickChek, Rosies Wine Bar, Swirl Wine Events and Town Hall Deli. Maplewood Veterans of Foreign  Wars is also a sponsor, considered by some to be an organization that glorifies war and violence. 
 
And as if this incongruous attitude were not bad enough, I made repeated requests for due process by seeking an opportunity to present my case before the committee, as is the obligation of a public entity that is custodian of  taxpayer money. These were ignored, in apparent violation of the New Jersey Open Public Meetings Act. This law specifically requires that public entities provide at least 48 hours advance notice of any meeting which affects the  public, minutes must be kept and a record maintained of any votes. 

If I so much as fail to dot an 'i' or cross a 't' in my business, the ATF, NJ State Police and Maplewood Police Department would come down on me like a ton of bricks. It is very hypocritical for this same government that demands 100% legal compliance in my field of endeavor to so blatantly ignore a law that is designed to prevent the very kind of arbitrary, capricious and unfair treatment they have shown me.
 
Matthew M. Carmel is president of Constitution Arms, a  federal and state-licensed  firearm retail  dealer and manufacturer located in Maplewood, N.J. The  company offers handgun training and sales. It is also developing an ergonomically novel handgun called the Palm Pistol which is designed for seniors, disabled and others with limited manual dexterity.

Patch_comments_icon

Mary Mann

1:07 pm on Friday, March 5, 2010

Craig Gruber tells Patch that the South Orange Maplewood Baseball Committee is a group of volunteers who help administer and operate the baseball program. He is not familiar with the New Jersey Open Public Meetings Act (or "Sunshine Law"). This law can be found in full on the New Jersey State Library website: http://www.njstatelib.org/LDB/Library_Law/lwopnmtg.php.

Reply

snow man

3:40 pm on Friday, March 5, 2010

Mr. Carmel

While I have no problem with a person being a licensed gun dealer, nor do I have any problem with legal gun ownership, you are obviously deluded if you are equating restaurants that serve liquor with liquor stores or manufacturers, delis that sell cigarettes with tobacco companies, and chicken take-out advertised by bodacious women as porn. It's not unreasonable for parents to object to having their children act as essentially spokesmen for a gun dealer, just as they would not unreasonably object if their Little League team were sponsored by Jack Daniels, RJ Reynolds or Penthouse.

Reply
Comment_arrow

cluck-u

8:47 pm on Friday, March 5, 2010

Mr. Snow Man:

Using your logic...you are obviously deluded if you are equating gun dealers that sell guns with gun manufactures...uh, what? I guess Wal-Mart is ok because they sell guns AND other items?

And I would guess in your eyes it is ok for little Timmy-6-year old to walk around as a spokesperson for Cluck-U? I would love to see little Timmy wear his uniform to school for show-and-tell.

Brian Henecker

6:36 pm on Friday, March 5, 2010

This is what happens when trying to have a gun business in an ultra liberal state and area...at least you tried.

Reply

snow man

12:24 am on Saturday, March 6, 2010

How's this: A strip club is legal; should one be able to sponsor a Little League team for that reason alone? Should Chico's Bail Bonds be allowed to sponsor a team? The league is not a public entity. It gets to choose who sponsors its teams if it needs sponsors to field teams. What Mr. Carmel fails to understand is that sponsorship is not a natural right and that some people see his business, legal or not, as unseemly, especially when related to children and in a town that borders on one of the murder capitols of New Jersey.

Reply

Karen Robilotta

11:49 am on Saturday, March 6, 2010

I now have an issue with the committee allowing Click-U to sponsor a team. Since when is demeaning, objectifying, insulting women something to be advertised? How is that okay ? Any women on this committee?

Reply

Phil

2:27 pm on Saturday, March 6, 2010

I don't think the softball league would be subject to open meetings law...but I am still disappointed in the process of the league rejecting this business. If they are going to have an open application for team sponsors, they ought to have a public process to vet those applications.
It is almost always the case that people confuse legal gun ownership with illegal crimes committed with guns. The overwhelming majority of gun crimes are committed with illegal guns and by criminals who ignore all laws. Presumably, this guy sells guns legally, and he runs a legitimate business in gun sales and training, he should be applauded, not shunned. You have the Maplewood VFW as sponsors, but reject a gun dealer...what do you think those veterans were armed with, toothpicks?

Reply

Leave a comment